<< NTDC >>

ADB Loan No.2289-PAK: Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
AWARD OF Contracts against Tender No.ADB-43-2008

LOT-I

For 220 kV Double Circuit Twin Bundle T/Line From Dherki CCPP to Engro CCPP
to 220kV Rohri New Grid Station

Sr.No.	Name of Bidder who submitted the bid	Quoted Bid Price Pak.Rs.	Corrected Bid Price Pak Rs.	Discounted/ Corrected Bid Price Pak Rs.	Evaluated Bid Price Pak Rs.	Reasons for Rejection if any	Winning Bidder Price Pak Rs.
1	M/s. Nazir & Company (Pvt.) Ltd., Lahore, Pakistan	414,831,996	415,356,006	402,895,326 (3% Discount)	402,895,326	See Note # 1
2	M/s. NPI Construction & Engineering, Karachi – Shams Construction Company, Quetta, Pakistan (JV)	382,496,507	421,645,964	421,645,964	421,645,964	See Note # 2
3	M/s. ICC (Pvt.) Ltd., Lahore, Pakistan	541,441,512	541,441,512	541,441,512	541,441,512	See Note # 3	541,441,512 See Note # 5
4	M/s. Potential Engineers (Pvt.) Ltd., Lahore, Pakistan	565,553,218	565,553,218	565,553,218	565,553,218	See Note # 4

NOTES

1	Due to deficient validity of bid security, defective authority letter, lack of equipment and incomplete financial documents.
2	Due to defective bid security and lack of experience, key personnel, equipment and inadequate financial capability.
3	Due to longer completion time and incomplete offer.
4	Due to shortfall in the average annual turn over.
5	Since none of the bidder was responsive for this lot, therefore, due to urgency of interconnection and to avoid heavy penalties M/s. ICC (Pvt.) Ltd. having better position was recommended subject to withdrawal of the deviations.

LOT-II

For 220 kV Double Circuit Twin Bundle T/Line From 220kV Rohri New Grid Station
to 220kV Shikarpur Grid Station

Sr.No.	Name of Bidder who submitted the bid	Quoted Bid Price Pak.Rs.	Corrected Bid Price Pak Rs.	Discounted/ Corrected Bid Price Pak Rs.	Evaluated Bid Price Pak Rs.	Reasons for Rejection if any	Winning Bidder Price Pak Rs.
1	M/s. NPI Construction & Engineering, Karachi – Shams Construction Company, Quetta, Pakistan (JV)	394,039,898	395,959,848	395,959,848	395,959,848	See Note # 1
2	M/s. ICC (Pvt.) Ltd., Lahore, Pakistan	448,924,505	448,924,505	448,924,505	448,924,505	See Note # 2
3	M/s. Potential Engineers (Pvt.) Ltd., Lahore, Pakistan	514,439,915	514,439,915	514,439,915	514,439,915		514,439,915
4	M/s. M.R. Electric – Al-Abdullah, Lahore, Pakistan (JV)	628,348,392	572,171,949	514,954,754 (10% Discount)	514,954,754	See Note # 4

NOTES

1	Due to defective bid security and lack of experience, key personnel, equipment and inadequate financial capability.
2	Due to longer completion time and incomplete offer.
3	Due to defective and deficient bid securities and lack of requisite stringing equipment.

LOT-III

i)	For 132kV Double Circuit T/Line from 220kV Rohri New Grid Station to 132kV Gumbat Grid Station.
ii)	For 132kV Double Circuit T/Line for In & Out of Two Circuits of Rohri - Khairpur/Gumbat T/Line at Rohri New Grid Station.

Sr.No.	Name of Bidder who submitted the bid	Quoted Bid Price Pak.Rs.	Corrected Bid Price Pak Rs.	Discounted/ Corrected Bid Price Pak Rs.	Evaluated Bid Price Pak Rs.	Reasons for Rejection if any	Winning Bidder Price Pak Rs.
1	M/s. M.R. Electric – Al-Abdullah, Lahore, Pakistan (JV)	173,074,555	173,074,555	133,267,407 (23% Discount)	133,267,407	See Note # 1
2	M/s. NPI Construction & Engineering, Karachi – Shams Construction Company, Quetta, Pakistan (JV)	146,950,083	146,724,944	146,724,944	146,724,944	See Note # 2
3	M/s. M. Yaqoob & Sons – Sami Construction Co., Quetta, Pakistan (JV)	152,992,005	149,395,725	149,395,725	149,395,725	See Note # 3
4	M/s. Usman & Company and M.R. Construction Company, Sukkur, Pakistan (JV)	162,271,300	162,271,300	162,271,300	162,271,300	See Note # 4
5	M/s. NEIE – Al-Hussain Traders, Lahore, Pakistan (JV)	198,963,192	198,963,192	198,963,192	198,963,192		198,963,192
6	M/s. Haji Nasib Khan & Co. (Pvt.) Ltd, Quetta, Pakistan	198,835,560	200,560,560	200,560,560	200,560,560	See Note # 5
7	M/s. Potential Engineers (Pvt.) Ltd., Lahore, Pakistan	230,019,800	230,019,770	230,019,770	230,019,770

NOTES

1	Due to defective and deficient bid securities and lack of requisite stringing equipment.
2	Due to defective bid security and lack of experience, key personnel, equipment and inadequate financial capability.
3	Due to defective bid securities and lack of experience, key personnel, equipment and incomplete financial documents.
4	Due to lack of experience, equipment and incomplete financial documents.
5	Due to lack of experience, key personnel, equipment and incomplete financial documents.

LOT-IV

For 132kV Double Circuit T/Line from Jarwar CCPP to 132kV
Sadiqabad Grid Station

Sr.No.	Name of Bidder who submitted the bid	Quoted Bid Price Pak.Rs.	Corrected Bid Price Pak Rs.	Discounted/ Corrected Bid Price Pak Rs.	Evaluated Bid Price Pak Rs.	Reasons for Rejection if any	Winning Bidder Price Pak Rs.
1	M/s. M.R. Electric – Al-Abdullah, Lahore, Pakistan (JV)	174,072,368	174,072,368	134,035,723 (23% Discount)	134,035,723	See Note # 1
2	M/s. NPI Construction & Engineering, Karachi – Shams Construction Company, Quetta, Pakistan (JV)	152,832,956	152,824,813	152,824,813	152,824,813	See Note # 2
3	M/s. NEIE – Al-Hussain Traders, Lahore, Pakistan (JV)	176,529,030	176,529,030	176,529,030	176,529,030		176,529,030
4	M/s. Haji Nasib Khan & Co. (Pvt.) Ltd, Quetta, Pakistan	199,907,100	199,907,100	199,907,100	199,907,100	See Note # 3
5	M/s. ICC (Pvt.) Ltd., Lahore, Pakistan	217,785,629	217,785,629	217,785,629	217,785,629	See Note # 4
6	M/s. Potential Engineers (Pvt.) Ltd., Lahore, Pakistan	227,918,762	227,918,762	227,918,762	227,918,762	See Note # 4

NOTES

1	Due to defective and deficient bid securities and lack of requisite stringing equipment.
2	Due to defective bid security and lack of experience, key personnel, equipment and inadequate financial capability.
3	Due to lack of experience, key personnel, equipment and incomplete financial documents.
4	Due to longer completion time and incomplete offer.